MaxiMuscle Progain vs Cyclone: Differences Explained

A picture of Best Mass Gainer UK founder, personal trainer Andy Williams
Written By
Andy Williams
Last Updated on

In this head-to-head supplement comparison, you’ll learn whether you should buy MaxiMuscle Progain or Cyclone based on your goals and needs.

Although these two protein supplements have their similarities, they’re actually very different when you examine the ingredients.

With that said, let’s dive into this quick MxiMuscle Cyclone vs Progain comparison.

The Key Differences Between Progain and Cyclone

MaxiMuscle Cyclone positioned next to a tub of MaxiMuscle Progain

These are the main differences between Progain and Cyclone that you need to know about.

  • Progain has 510 calories per serving, whereas Cyclone only has 204 calories per shake
  • The Progain serving size (120g) is exactly twice that of Cyclone (60g)
  • Progain provides 10 servings per tub, while Cyclone gives you 21 servings per tub
  • Progain contains 38g of protein from whey and calcium caseinate, whereas Cyclone has 31g of protein from whey isolate, whey concentrate, and whey hydrolysate
  • Progain contains 53g of carbs and 14g of fat, while Cyclone only has 10g of carbs and 1.6g of fat
  • Cyclone has 5g of creatine and 1.6g of HMB, whereas Progain has neither

Should You Get Progain or Cyclone?

A side by side MaxiMuscle Cyclone vs MaxiMuscle Progain comparison to show the differences

So, should you buy Progain or Cyclone? If you’re a hardgainer who needs plenty of extra calories, go with Progain because it has 300 more calories than Cyclone, along with extra protein, carbs, and fats.

On the other hand, if you’re looking for an all-in-one formula for lean gaining and don’t have a really high calorie requirement, then Cyclone is the way to go because it has fewer calories than Progain and a more protein-dense formula (less overall protein, but more protein on a per 100g basis). Plus, Cyclone gives you twice as many servings as Progian, making it more economical.

I’m reluctant to say that one is better than the other because the ideal choice for you heavily depends on your goals.

Yes, Progain will work out more expensive, but mass gainers, by definition, are costly supplements because they have larger serving sizes and, as such, don’t last as long as leaner protein powders like Cyclone.

To see full reviews of each supplement, you can read my MaxiNutrition Cyclone review or my MaxiNutrition Progain review. But honestly, I’ll cover pretty much everything in this comparison to try and save you time!

MaxiMuscle Progain vs Cyclone: Taste and Mixing

Image showing the differences between MaxiNutrition Cyclone and MaxiNutrition Progain

As you might expect, both Progain and Cyclone taste virtually the same, given that they’re made by MaxiNutrition and have the exact same flavour selection.

For me, these are two of the best-tasting supplements that you can buy. As one of the oldest supplement brands in the UK, MaxiNutrition (aka MaxiMuscle) has had years of experience in perfecting its flavours, and it shows with Cyclone and Progain.

Progain is a bit thicker than Cyclone because it’s more calorie-dense, but you can always adjust the consistency of either shake to suit your preferences by adding more or less liquid (or by using milk rather than water).

Both Progain and Cyclone give you a lump-free shake that’s a joy to drink. So, while they are more expensive than comparable supplements, you definitely get that bit of extra quality and peace of mind when you buy a MaxiNutrition protein powder/mass gainer.

ideal for lean gains
A tub of Cyclone by MaxiMuscle
MaxiMuscle Cyclone

MaxiMuscle Progain vs Cyclone: Ingredient Quality

Image showing what Cyclone or Progain look like from MaxiMuscle

In terms of ingredient quality, there really aren’t any big differences between Cyclone and Progain.

However, the specific ingredients used in each formula are quite different. Let me explain.

Progain has a 38g blend of whey and calcium caseinate, so you’re getting both fast-acting and slow-digesting proteins, which should help your muscles stay in an anabolic (growing and repairing) state for longer.

On the other hand, Cyclone has a 31g protein blend consisting of 3 different types of whey protein (concentrate, isolate, and hydrolysate). As such, Cyclone provides only quick-release protein, so while the initial muscle protein synthesis spike will be slightly higher, you won’t get that steady supply of amino acids over a longer period of time, as you will with Progain.

If you’re going to be eating again soon after your shake, then this doesn’t really matter. But if you want to make the protein go as far as possible, then Progain likely has a slight advantage.

Progain is also considerably higher in fat and carbohydrates, making it a better choice for those who need to cram in extra calories in order to gain weight.

Cyclone, however, contains creatine, which increases your strength, and HMB, which minimises protein breakdown (and thereby muscle loss). So, if you’re looking for a convenient, all-in-one formula for lean gaining, then Cyclone is definitely the way to go. 

ideal for bulking
A tub of Progain by MaxiNutrition
MaxiMuscle Progain

Which Is Better Value?

The powder scoops from MaxiMuscle Cyclone and MaxiMuscle Progain

As I said earlier in this MaxiMuscle Cyclone vs Progain comparison, mass gainers are, by nature, expensive because the serving sizes are usually very large.

Therefore, it’s no surprise that Cyclone provides 21 servings per tub while Progain only gives you 10 servings per tub.

Yet, Progain is more than twice as calorie-dense as Cyclone on a per-serving basis, meaning that it’s still better value for those who could really use the extra calories.

Sure, you don’t get creatine and HMB, as with Cyclone, but these supplements are quite cheap to buy in bulk nowadays.

Of course, if you’re lean gaining, the Cyclone will last you twice as long as Progain. But as I’ve maintained from the start, one supplement isn’t necessarily superior to the other because they cater to different training goals.

The Verdict: Should You Buy MaxiMuscle Cyclone or Progain?

A closeup MaxiMuscle Cyclone vs Progain comparison

Regardless of whether you get MaxiMuscle Cyclone or Progain, you’re not going to be disappointed because both protein supplements are, I have to say, of an exceptional quality that you rarely find in the supplement industry.

I know this because I’ve tested about 70 different mass gainers!

Still, to get the best results, you want to choose the supplement that best aligns with your needs and goals.

So if you’re more of the hardgainer type, have a fast metabolism, or just need the extra calories, go with MaxiNutrition Progain.

Conversely, if you’re trying to make lean gains and don’t have an especially high calorie requirement, then MaxiNutrition Cyclone is the best option.

I hope that my Progain vs Cyclone comparison was helpful. As you can see, both supplements have their place, and the best choice for you really depends on your training goals.

for hardgainers
A tub of Progain by MaxiNutrition
MaxiMuscle Progain
A picture of Best Mass Gainer UK founder, personal trainer Andy Williams
Andy Williams
Andy Williams is a UK-based personal trainer and bodybuilder who coaches gym-goers of all levels using proven evidence-based techniques in strength training, nutrition, and supplementation. He’s tested over 70 different mass gainers for their ingredient quality and muscle-building effectiveness and regularly shares his findings in his mass gainer reviews.
the logo for Best Mass Gainer UK showing a tub of weight gainer protein powder
We test and review every mass gainer and weight gainer on the UK market so that British fitness enthusiasts can make informed supplementation decisions.
Copyright © 2024 Best Mass Gainer UK All Rights Reserved
chevron-upmenu-circlecross-circle linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram